“You’re either with us, or against us…”
Black or white. In or out. One of President George W. Bush’s
most quoted, lines. One of his
most referred to, thoughts. My Cuban mother still says that much to Pres. Bush’s chagrin, it’s something Fidel Castro would have said in the early 1960’s.
I always assumed President Bush’s inability – or perhaps better said, lack of desire – to see the subtleties of public policy imperatives and foreign policy issues stemmed from a lack of interest in engaging with ideas. Not necessarily a lack of interest in engaging with people, mind you. But lack of interest in engaging with their ideas – especially if those ideas were different from his own. I always rather suspected he had no problem sitting across the table with people who had lived a different life experience than he had. I imagine him being rather interested in hearing other folks’ stories – just not necessarily, their ideas. Over a non-alcoholic beer.
Enter present-day Texas Gov. Rick Perry. I have now listened to, and read the text to his
Presidential bid announcement speech various times. I have learned he thinks
Ben Bernanke's economic policy borders on treason. I now know he
questions President Obama's patriotism. I surmise that he has some problems with evolution, since he seems to think if you teach both creationism and evolution, most are
"smart enough to figure out which one is right." And most of all, I know he believes in
abstinence education, not because he has some personal preference for it – which is not in and of itself a bad thing – but because despite all evidence to the contrary, he says "it works."
For years I heard that one of President Bush's saving graces was that he was a likable guy. I admit to never quite getting that, but I did always view him as someone who liked being around other people – even if only superficially. Right now, all I can see in Gov. Perry's Texas twang and swagger is not only someone who is not particularly interested in those who have lived a different life experience, but frankly, someone who thinks better of his own experience than that of other Americans. There's nothing wrong with being from small-town America and marrying your high school sweetheart. Quite the contrary, But hey, that's not the only way to be. Not the only life to have led.
If Gov. Perry doesn't make his own life experience more accessible to a greater number of Americans, they ain't gonna like him. They won't be able to relate to him. They won't think he's a likable guy. Which means he ain't going no where. And the only way for him to do that is by appearing to be more interested in, and sympathetic to the lives of others, and attempt to point out commonalities of experience. After all, it's the American way.
Not quite President Bush's version of my-way-or-the-highway. But a version, none-the-less.