The
voices we heard from Madison, Wisconsin this week.
The
voices of at least 70,000 protesters at the State Capitol this weekend. Out in the snowy, cold. Voices speaking out against Gov. Scott Walker’s plan to end most collective bargaining rights for state workers.
The
voice of Capitol Police Chief Charles Tubbs, as he announced that the
protesters would not be cleared from the Capitol.
Police decided not to forcibly remove protesters after thousands ignored a 4 p.m. Sunday deadline to leave so the normally immaculate building could get a thorough cleaning. Capitol Police Chief Charles Tubbs said no demonstrators will be arrested as long as they continue to obey the law.
"People here have acted lawfully and responsibly," Tubbs said. "There's no reason to consider arrests."
The
lone, representative voice of labor on yesterday’s Sunday morning shows,
Richard Trumka, defending the
silence of one voice so many want to hear on this one – the voice of President Obama.
AFL-CIO President Richard Trumka gave his blessing Sunday to President Obama's handling of the labor standoff in Wisconsin.
Amid some criticism on the left that Obama could do more to boost unions in their demonstrations against Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker, and his proposal to eliminate most collective bargaining rights for public workers, Trumka said the president was doing just fine.
"I think he's doing it the right way," Trumka said on NBC's "Meet the Press"
Voices from the Congressional Progressive Caucus saying
just the opposite. The emphasis is mine.
"I think the statements the president made supporting collective bargaining and organized labor are important," Rep. Raul Grijalva (D-AZ) told reporters on a Wednesday conference call organized by the Progressive Change Campaign Committee. "I think that there is more to do.
While the issue is clear and in front of us in Wisconsin, it does have national ramifications...There's a bully pulpit there that the president has and I think it needs to be used, it needs to be used to rally national support, and I hope that role is part of I believe the president's undertaken aggressively because this is not just an isolated regional state fight in Wisconsin. This has ramifications for national policy...I don't think you can turn the cheek on this one, this is one where you have to be very firm.
His co-chair, Rep. Keith Ellison (D-MN) made the same point Wednesday evening on MSNBC.
"Of course I'd like to hear more from President Obama," Ellison said. " He's made some statements, he should get credit for that, we'd like to hear him make some more statements. I think President Obama should come to Wisconsin and stand with the workers."
The
silencing of voices, as the Wisconsin State Assembly cut off debate on the proposal, in the wee hours of the morning.
After a bitter, 61-hour debate that was the longest in living memory, the sleep-starved state Assembly voted in just seconds early Friday to approve a watershed proposal repealing most union bargaining rights held by public workers.
Just after 1 a.m., Republicans cut off debate on Gov. Scott Walker's bill and in pell-mell fashion the body voted 51-17 to pass it. In the confusion, nearly one-third of the body - 28 lawmakers including 25 Democrats, two Republicans and the body's lone independent - did not vote on the bill at all.
All Democrats voted against the proposal along with four Republicans - Dean Kaufert of Neenah, Lee Nerison of Westby, Richard Spanbauer of Oshkosh, and Travis Tranel of Cuba City.
Democrats erupted after the vote, throwing papers and what appeared to be a drink in the air. They denounced the move to cut off debate, questioning for the second time in the night whether the proper procedure had been followed.
But, perhaps best of all this week was the
voice of Wisconsin Governor Scott Walker getting PUNKED! He took a 20-minute call from investigative journalist Ian Murphy from the on-line magazine
Buffalo Beast, as he pretending to be billionaire and big-bucks-Walker-supporter David Koch.
So much has been said, written, video-taped about this encounter. But,
the voice of Cenk Uyger on his MSNBC television show right after the encounter, says it all. He is incredulous. As well, he should be. A remarkable encounter.
Baseball bats. Advertising dollars. Trips to "Cali."
We like to think that through the
voices of our elected officials, we get a glimpse into how they think. What they want to accomplish. Despite what Gov. Walker has said about his public policy imperatives, it's not brain surgery what
he thinks. His budget proposal is about nothing but trying to strip workers of their rights in Wisconsin, and then taking his show on the road. But, as despicable as that is, at least it's as public policy stance. What is remarkable about his telephone encounter with the fake Koch brother, is that it tells us not what Gov. Walker (really) thinks about an issue of our day,
but who really he is.
And if you're no careful, once in a while
a lone voice when left to its own devices, can do just that.